Primary ICT - Laptop Pros and Cons
An investigation into whether ICT suites in primary schools are becoming redundant in favour of wirefree laptops that are integrated into the classroom.
The headteacher and staff at Fowey Primary School in Cornwall discuss the pros and cons of their 15-strong fixed-location PC suite as opposed to a fleet of 16 leased laptops.
This programme will be particularly useful for primary headteachers looking to develop their ICT resources.
greenalien on 21 October 2006
Not mentioned in the video, but worth thinking about : 1) Laptops typically consume about 1/3 of the power of Desktop ...
Go down to this comment
- Duration: 15:00 minutes
- Published: 17 December 2005
- Licence information for Primary ICT - Laptop Pros and Cons
Featured in
Support Materials
Downloads
Comments
-
-
Further Considerations21 October 2006 - 17:40Not mentioned in the video, but worth thinking about :
1) Laptops typically consume about 1/3 of the power of Desktop machines. Lower running costs helps to offset the higher capital cost, and they produce less heat. As they also consume less resources to make, they win the eco-friendly vote.
2) Reliability remains an issue. Laptops are portable but not ruggedised (with a few premium-priced exceptions). Getting a good warranty is essential, with 3 years now being typical. As specialist repair of laptops is expensive, consider selling them off at the end of the warranty period, after wiping off all data, and replacing them with new machines. As the government now allows IT equipment to be written off 100% against tax in 3 years, this would seem to be the optimum solution. Incidentally, the same consideration applies to video projectors, for the same reasons.
3) The typing position for the keyboards of most laptops isn't very good. Fortunately, add-on, more ergonomic keyboards are relatively cheap, and have the additional benefit of saving wear on the inbuilt keyboard; a similar consideration applies to using an external mouse - - much easier to use for most people than a glidepad or trackpoint, and cheap to replace.
4) Small Form-factor PC's are rapidly adopting many of the advantages of laptops as far as low power consumption and small size are concerned, and have greater expansion possibilities than most laptops. Laptops don't tend to have great graphics, except at a premium price, so if you need a machine for advanced graphics work, such as video editing, a SFF PC with a good graphics card and a large TFT monitor could offer better value for money.
5) The price of TFT monitors has been dropping for some time; their low running costs compared to CRT monitors makes it worth upgrading sooner rather later; there are also space considerations that act in favour of the same argument.
6) Wireless networks are great if they are secure; a major liability otherwise. Don't leave the task of setting up a network to someone who doesn't fully understand the security issues. e.g. choosing and enabling an appropriate encryption standard ; setting up specified MAC addressing ; setting up firewalls; setting up and maintaining network passwords, particularly for shared file access. In particular, never leave the security settings of a wireless access point / router as their default values.
-
You might also like
Two teenagers explore the pros and cons of online medical records
Different approaches to sourcing funds for ICT
Teachers discuss the issues involved in ICT development
Editor's pick
KS1/2 Literacy - Reading Film at KS1: DanglePhil Traill explains the making of Dangle, his short film












Delicious
Digg
StumbleUpon
Reddit
Facebook